Thor
Member
Why can't this moment last forever more?
Posts: 22,606
|
Post by Thor on Mar 10, 2004 9:54:13 GMT 1
Ooooops, Helga was right! 'tis true, nigel lythgoe told me himself
|
|
Thor
Member
Why can't this moment last forever more?
Posts: 22,606
|
Post by Thor on Mar 11, 2004 19:08:02 GMT 1
whta do you think of the 4 that went through
overall i'm happy with the picks
but 1 i think should be there. on ei thought was popular and got through because of that, another i thought would ahve been overlooked and the other i was hoping would get in and did.
|
|
|
Post by David on Mar 11, 2004 22:24:02 GMT 1
I'm not sold, I particularly dislike one of them, the other three fair enough...
|
|
|
Post by David on Mar 12, 2004 22:55:47 GMT 1
OK, the David rankings for the wildcard:
1. Jennifer Hudson 2. Susie Vulaca 3. Elizabeth LeTendre 4. George Huff 5. Leah LaBelle 6. Katie Webber 7. Matthew Metzger 8, Jon Peter Lewis
|
|
|
Post by Xerox on Mar 12, 2004 23:14:08 GMT 1
Jon Peter Lewis was f***ing AWFUL, it was like he was drunk and grabbed the mic and jumped up on stage...just DREADFUL...
Matthew Metzger seems a really nice guy and he has the most gorgeous smile, but he didn't stand out much with his performance. Katie Webber really seemed to struggle with her vocals.
Highlight for me tonight was Susan Vulaca - I liked her a lot last week and I thought she was just as great tonight.
|
|
|
Post by Xerox on Mar 12, 2004 23:17:18 GMT 1
Reuben won American Idol 2, right? Did he get much comment from the judges about his weight - the usual "you don't look like an American Idol..." comments?
|
|
|
Post by David on Mar 12, 2004 23:25:34 GMT 1
I thought she was better than last week, for the sole reason that NOBODY is ever gonna eclipse Toni Braxton on 'Unbreak My Heart'...
I am GUTTED at some of the choices...
|
|
|
Post by David on Mar 12, 2004 23:27:33 GMT 1
Reuben won American Idol 2, right? Did he get much comment from the judges about his weight - the usual "you don't look like an American Idol..." comments? I think he did a bit at the beginning, but they were always going on about how AI2 was a battle of image and talent, and that was borne out by the final 3, none of them conventionally good looking (though Kim Locke COULD look good)... while all the pretty people got kicked off...
|
|
|
Post by Xerox on Mar 12, 2004 23:32:14 GMT 1
Leah LaBelle really is NOTHING special...
|
|
|
Post by David on Mar 12, 2004 23:35:29 GMT 1
Leah LaBelle really is NOTHING special... I think she'll probably be first gone, unless she DOES actually surprise everyone next week, Elizabeth or Susie would be a much better choice...
|
|
|
Post by Xerox on Mar 12, 2004 23:41:57 GMT 1
JON PETER LEWIS?? ?? ?? ?? ?? ?? ?? ??
f***ing HELL....................................................
|
|
|
Post by David on Mar 12, 2004 23:45:50 GMT 1
It's gonna be the Latoya/Fantasia show fairly much I think,
|
|
|
Post by Xerox on Mar 12, 2004 23:47:01 GMT 1
Those are the only two who stand out for me. If they make it to the final, it could be a VERY interesting showdown.
|
|
|
Post by Star on Mar 12, 2004 23:52:23 GMT 1
Ooooooooh! I was surprised at Simon's choice! I thought he would go for Susie - I think she deserved to be in the top 12. Again the 2 that stand out for me are Latoya and Fantasia! Jennifer has a good voice but did you notice her facial expressions when singing?? ;D ;D Leah was OK, but not brilliant.
|
|
|
Post by David on Mar 12, 2004 23:54:51 GMT 1
I think 9 girls/3 guys would have been too unbalanced for the audience, I'm not keen on some of the choices... Susie DESERVED final 12...
|
|
|
Post by Xerox on Mar 12, 2004 23:58:34 GMT 1
Susie DESERVED final 12... AbsoLUTELY....
|
|
Thor
Member
Why can't this moment last forever more?
Posts: 22,606
|
Post by Thor on Mar 13, 2004 1:04:09 GMT 1
still Diana for me!
|
|
|
Post by David on Mar 13, 2004 1:19:37 GMT 1
I dunno how much Diana can grow, she's already an alumnus of Star Search...
|
|
Thor
Member
Why can't this moment last forever more?
Posts: 22,606
|
Post by Thor on Mar 13, 2004 13:12:18 GMT 1
I dunno how much Diana can grow, she's already an alumnus of Star Search... what is that supposed to mean?
|
|
|
Post by David on Mar 13, 2004 14:42:33 GMT 1
what is that supposed to mean? Well, she, unlike many of the others, has prior experience of performing live on TV, she was a 'Star Search' champion last year, which, while it gives her an advantage in the early going, MIGHT mean that she's close to as good as she can get... while other people around her will get better, a bit like Kimberly Caldwell last year (who was in US Popstars 2) God I feel like I know too much!
|
|