|
xfactor
Aug 21, 2006 13:22:46 GMT 1
Post by xxxnicolaxxx on Aug 21, 2006 13:22:46 GMT 1
I liked Johnathan he was really good, Although I didn't like him singing swing.
I thought the young boy at 16 was sweet but I don't think he will be able to cope if he gets a grilling from the judges, He was too nervous and kept shaking bless him.
The old woman with her daughter was funny, Simon was a bit gobsmacked at the way she reacted towards their comments. I thought she was gonna smack him in the face.
True Liberty I think they were called were great, I liked their voices and they seemed to have great personalities.
|
|
|
xfactor
Aug 21, 2006 13:24:48 GMT 1
Post by Razzle Dazzle on Aug 21, 2006 13:24:48 GMT 1
so is there 4 judges this year?
what if 2 says yes and 2 say no?
|
|
|
xfactor
Aug 21, 2006 13:29:15 GMT 1
Post by xxxnicolaxxx on Aug 21, 2006 13:29:15 GMT 1
so is there 4 judges this year? what if 2 says yes and 2 say no? There are still 3 judges, Paula Abdul was just an extra for a bit. I don't think she's actually staying.
|
|
|
xfactor
Aug 21, 2006 14:07:57 GMT 1
Post by LittleChristmasTurkey on Aug 21, 2006 14:07:57 GMT 1
True Liberty reminded me of a less good Voices With Soul from xfactor 1. Great singers, great personalities, but they just didn't get the votes in.
|
|
|
xfactor
Aug 21, 2006 18:13:15 GMT 1
Post by *~Julzywoo~* on Aug 21, 2006 18:13:15 GMT 1
i liked true liberty too, and jonathon *swoon* i want him to win already lol
|
|
|
Post by LittleChristmasTurkey on Aug 22, 2006 9:23:56 GMT 1
Jonathan with his fake-ill mum?
|
|
|
xfactor
Aug 22, 2006 10:01:29 GMT 1
Post by Anne-Marie on Aug 22, 2006 10:01:29 GMT 1
How do you know she's fake??
|
|
Melody
Member
"Once in every lifetime comes a love like this"
Posts: 1,086
|
xfactor
Aug 22, 2006 11:57:45 GMT 1
Post by Melody on Aug 22, 2006 11:57:45 GMT 1
Not enjoying this series very much so far. Getting a bit tired of the exploitation of the hopeless and delusional. I really liked the vocal group - felt so much for the poor little lad who was crippled with nerves - didnt like Jonathan very much. Love Melody xx
|
|
|
xfactor
Aug 22, 2006 12:13:45 GMT 1
Post by LittleChristmasTurkey on Aug 22, 2006 12:13:45 GMT 1
Not enjoying this series very much so far. Getting a bit tired of the exploitation of the hopeless and delusional. But that's how X Factor has always been. And Pop Idol before it. And Pop Stars and Fame Academy too. The group who sang Carpenters, or True Liberty? Both were fairly good I suppose. I didn't feel for the shy guy at all. Why the hell did he bother going? The music industry would tear him apart before he even got started, he got half the words wrong, and although he was in tune, he didn't have a particularly strong voice. No way should he have gone through.
|
|
Melody
Member
"Once in every lifetime comes a love like this"
Posts: 1,086
|
xfactor
Aug 22, 2006 14:07:19 GMT 1
Post by Melody on Aug 22, 2006 14:07:19 GMT 1
That's very true - it's just that it's beginning to make me feel guilty and uneasy about watching people being exploited. I think it's come from discovering that the people are auditioned by others before coming in front of the panel - so the chosing of bad ones is deliberate to make the programme. When I didnt know that and thought they all sang for the panel I could enjoy it better. I meant the group that sang the Carpenters - I liked. I dont think the young boy should have gone through either - he's far too fragile for a show like the X factor - but I couldnt help but feel for him - nerves can be so destructive.......and so hard to overcome. Love Melody xx
|
|
|
xfactor
Aug 22, 2006 15:18:22 GMT 1
Post by LittleChristmasTurkey on Aug 22, 2006 15:18:22 GMT 1
Oh, didn't you know that? It was like it in Pop Idol 2 when I auditioned (I was fab, by the way ) so I can only assume it's been the same for the other series too, but I could be wrong. I do think it's kind of cruel to build these people up by putting them through, then send them crashing back down, but that's all part of the fun!
|
|
Paul
Member
*Pantomime Villain!*
Posts: 13,460
|
xfactor
Sept 30, 2006 21:14:16 GMT 1
Post by Paul on Sept 30, 2006 21:14:16 GMT 1
*Bumping from the 5th page * I am really annoyed that that stupid little nervous kid (Sean?) got through. It's a typical Simon Cowell sympathy case. Glad though that the band that didn't rehearse and were part of the Brothers from last year are out
|
|
|
xfactor
Sept 30, 2006 21:17:12 GMT 1
Post by *~Julzywoo~* on Sept 30, 2006 21:17:12 GMT 1
yeah that guy was a right arrogant pr**k, oh i will ust go on hol now, oh we wont bother rehearsing, that showed him, i think simon has got soft over the years am i the only one who cries at x factor every week?
|
|
Arcadia
Member
*Yummy Mummy!*
Posts: 29,866
|
xfactor
Sept 30, 2006 21:21:51 GMT 1
Post by Arcadia on Sept 30, 2006 21:21:51 GMT 1
*Bumping from the 5th page * I am really annoyed that that stupid little nervous kid (Sean?) got through. It's a typical Simon Cowell sympathy case. Glad though that the band that didn't rehearse and were part of the Brothers from last year are out I think it's probably the producers rather than Cowell that's put him through. They've latched onto him as 'good telly'.
|
|
Arcadia
Member
*Yummy Mummy!*
Posts: 29,866
|
xfactor
Sept 30, 2006 21:22:09 GMT 1
Post by Arcadia on Sept 30, 2006 21:22:09 GMT 1
am i the only one who cries at x factor every week? No, I do too!
|
|
Arcadia
Member
*Yummy Mummy!*
Posts: 29,866
|
xfactor
Sept 30, 2006 21:22:29 GMT 1
Post by Arcadia on Sept 30, 2006 21:22:29 GMT 1
Did Rudi get through?
|
|
|
xfactor
Sept 30, 2006 21:25:25 GMT 1
Post by *~Julzywoo~* on Sept 30, 2006 21:25:25 GMT 1
thats ok then, which was Rudi again?
|
|
Arcadia
Member
*Yummy Mummy!*
Posts: 29,866
|
xfactor
Sept 30, 2006 21:26:52 GMT 1
Post by Arcadia on Sept 30, 2006 21:26:52 GMT 1
The one who got rejected by Cowell in Dublin (when Sharon wasn't there) then came over to Glasgow and still got rejected by Cowell, but put through by the other two, then he ended up in Cowell's group...
|
|
Paul
Member
*Pantomime Villain!*
Posts: 13,460
|
xfactor
Sept 30, 2006 21:59:21 GMT 1
Post by Paul on Sept 30, 2006 21:59:21 GMT 1
No he didn't. But Simon didn't put him out at the first opportunity
|
|
|
Post by Chris on Oct 1, 2006 11:53:31 GMT 1
How the hec is that nervous young kid going to cope with live tv if he forgets all the songs?
|
|